Should I get Marc Jacobs Daisy Eau so Fresh or Coach's new scent Poppy?

So all winter I've been wearing Burberry Brit- which I love. But for the summer I'm looking for something a little fresher. I'm currently between Marc Jacob's Daisy Eau so Fresh (an eau du toilette) and Coach's Poppy (perfume). Any preferences? Any reason one's better than the other? I love both scents in magazines/ when i've smelled them at Lord and Taylor... but I'm looking to find out if one last longer, fades to a weird scent, etc.